Tiltak for en mer helhetlig konkurransepolitikk

Report 2010/6

Ingeborg Rasmussen og Steinar Strøm

Tiltak for en mer helhetlig konkurransepolitikk

Category	Reports
Sub-Categories	n/a
Year	2010
Report Number	6
Author(s)	Ingeborg Rasmussen Steinar Strøm
Download	file_download (430.2 kB)
Read in browser	PDF

!!"#$%&'!()*!+,!-+*!.+$.+%$#/!'),'0**&,1+2)$#%#''!!!3!+,!)4+*)*5,+%!40*5+*#,/!&4!+,!0%4#5+$1+!&4!6),'0**&,1+%#$17,+%1!*)$$+!)/!)22/&4+*!!8,/+9)*/!:&1-011+,!)/!;%+#,&*!;%*<-!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!,&--.,%!(,/!0121314!!!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!2!!""#$%&''<&88+(=,&://///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////0!2!>(()+=(#(://////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////?!2/2!@&6:,;((///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////?!2/0!A,.B)+8$%#))#(:+,!.:!&C:,+($(#(:///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////D!0!E%7.,=,#(:+,!C+=!=&:+($!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////4!0/2!F.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!C#,6$.89+%+,////////////////////////////////////////////////4!0/0!G,:&(#$+,#(:!&C!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66+(!#!H.,:+//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////I!0/J!K,7&,#(:+,!.:!C;,=+,#(:+,!7,&!<C+,#:+!.:!L&(8&,6//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////21!0/?!K6$+8-+)!-M!;%7.,=,#(:+,////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////20!J!5#)%&6!7.,!8+,!)#6+C+,=#:!6.(6;,,&($+////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2?!J/2!E%7.,=,#(:+,N!%#)%&6!.:!C#,6+8#=)+,///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2?!J/0!<&87;(($O6.(.8#$6!+77+6%#C#%+%//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2D!J/J!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%P!E%C#=+%!,.))+!.:!&($C&,/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2Q!J/?!<*(+,:#+,!7.,!8&,6+=+%R///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////01!J/D!<&87;(($O6.(.8#$6+!C#,6(#(:+,/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////02!J/4!SC&!B+%*,!%#)%&6+%!7.,!(.,$6+!B+=,#7%+,R/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////04!T+7+,&($+,///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////0I!''

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!0!Sammendrag ($")*++,"-.'/0'%1).'21%)0+'U+=!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!8+(+$!=+%!#!=+%%+!(.%&%+%!+(!$&8.,=(#(:!8+=!7+))+$!7.,C&)%(#(:!&CP!!• F.(6;,,&($+).C+(!• T+:+)C+,6!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!&($6&77+)$+,!• F.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!&6%O,+,!•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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!?!1 Innledning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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!D!$%O,,+!7,#9+%!.:!$+)C$%*,+/!>!&(=,+!%#)7+))+,!+,!7.,+%&6+(+!B)#%%!.--7.,=,+%!%#)!M!+%&B)+,+!(*+!7.,,+%(#(:$.8,M=+,!#!=+(!9+($#6%!M!O6+!#((%X+(#(:+(!.:!,+=;$+,+!B+9.C+%!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!%#)$6;==/!'F.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!7.,+%&6!B)#,!#!=+!7)+$%+!%#)7+))+,!$+%%!-M!$.8!-.$#%#C%!=+,$.8!=+%!B#=,&,!%#)!+77+6%#C#%+%N!B+=,+!6C&)#%+%!.:!$%O,,+!C&):7,#9+%!7.,!B,;6+,(+/!<&8%#=#:!C#$+,!+,7&,#(:+(+!&%!6.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!C#,6$.89+%+,!:#,!(*+!;%7.,=,#(:+,!.:!,+#$+,!+(!,+66+!$-O,$8M)!6(*%%+%!%#)!,.))+&C6)&,#(:!.:!6.(6;,,&($+!-M!)#6+!C#)6M,/!E%7.,=,#(:+(+!6.88+,!#!7O,$%+!,+66+!$.8!7O):+!&C!&%!.77+(%)#:+!C#,6$.89+%+,!.7%+!9&,!+(!8*(=#:9+%$B+$%+8%!$\,$%#))#(:!.:!=+,7.,!.-+,+,+,!;(=+,!&(=,+!,&88+B+%#(:+)$+,!+((!%#)$C&,+(=+!-,#C&%+!C#,6$.89+%+,/!!C.#$2'6$+'."'5.+'-,5%.9')$")*++,"-./$%191))'>!3*-+&!-)',&*-!40-"1((*-'#$,5$&!"#$/!&"5(!VHSGN!0121W!7.,$)M,!HSG!&%!=+%!;%&,B+#=+$!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66/!<.8!+(!=+)!&C!=+%!$%,&%+:#$6+!&,B+#=+%!O($6+%!HSG!+(!+6$%+,(N!;&C9+(:#:!:X+((.8:&(:!&C!B+9.C+%!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!=+,!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%!:#$!+%!;%C#=+%!8&(=&%/!!!E1-9,'@",%?-.''"#$%&!'(&)*$+!9&,!-M!.--=,&:!7,&!HSG!:#%%!+(!7O,$%+!.C+,.,=(+%!C;,=+,#(:!&C!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66/!";,=+,#(:+(+!B*::+,!-M!+(!+(6+)!=+$6$%;=#+!7.,&(6,+%!#!$&87;(($O6.(.8#$6!%+.,#!.:!+8-#,#/!!ABF >+$8%.5-91%%1":.+'$:',2:+."-"1":''G"'-,5%.9')$")*++,"-./$%191))''U+=!+(!$&8)+%!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!8+(+$!+(!$&8.,=(#(:!&CP!!'• F.(6;,,&($+).C+(!• T+:+)C+,6!7.,!.77+(%)#:!&($6&77+)$+,!• F.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!&6%O,+,!•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tfordringer ved dagens konkurransepolitikk FBA ($")*++,"-.'5.%%$5'$66."9%1:.'$:'/+12,9.'21+)-$5#.9.+''A,.B)+8$%#))#(:+,!6(*%%+%!%#)!6.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!C#,6$.89+%+,!+,!C+,6+(!(*+N!+))+,!$\,+:(+!7.,!H.,:+/!T+:;)+,#(:!&C!8&,6+=$=+)%&:+)$+!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!7.,+%&6!.:!6.(6;,,&($+7.,9.)=+%!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!7.,+%&6!C&,!+6$+8-+)C#$!%+8&!-M!+(!,;(=+B.,=$6.(7+,&($+!&,,&(:+,%!&C!GK`L!#!011?/!>!<C+,#:+!9&,!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!V011aW!-M!B&6:,;((!&C!.87&%%+(=+!;%,+=(#(:+,!;%&,B+#=+%!7.,$)&:!%#)!+(!,+66+!%#)%&6!7.,!B+=,+!6.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!7.,+%&6/!!E%7.,=,#(:+(+!$.8!&=,+$$+,+$!#!;)#6+!;%,+=(#(:+,!+,!#!$%.,+!%,+66!=+!$&88+N!.:!:X+)=+,!-M!%C+,$!&C!(&$X.(+,/!K,7&,#(:+(+!$.8!,+7+,+,+$!#!<%/8+)=/!(,!2D!V011?Z011DW!$&88+(7&))+,!8+=!#(%+,(&$X.(&)+!+,7&,#(:+,/!U+)=#(:+(!-+6+,!B)&(%!&((+%!-M!&%P!!($")*++,"-.'/0'%1).'• >!C#,6$.89+%!$.8!.-+,+,+,!BM=+!#!+%!$6X+,8+%!.:!+%!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%!8&,6+=N!B)#,!7+))+$6.$%(&=+,!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!Q!21%)0+I'',+:($6&-$7O,%!#!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(N!.:!6.$%(&=$B+)&$%(#(:+(!C+)%+$!.C+,!-M!B,;6+,(+!&C!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!%X+(+$%+(/!• L+%!.C+,#(C+$%+,+$!#!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(!.:!)+=#:!6&-&$#%+%!B,;6+$!%#)!M!-,.=;$+,+!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!%X+(+$%+,/!• L+%!#(C+$%+,+$!#!-,.=;6$X.($%+6(.).:#!#!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(!$.8!:#,!)&C+!8&,:#(&)6.$%(&=+,!7.,!=+(!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(/!• E)#69+%+,!#!,&88+B+%#(:+)$+,!.:!,+:;)+,#(:+,!6&(!:#!6.(6;,,&($+C,#=(#(:+,!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:!&6%O,+,/!",#=(#(:+(+!6&(!#!$#(!%;,!7O,+!%#)!&%!&(=,+!7.,9.)=!+((!,++))!6.(6;,,&($+=*6%#:9+%!&C:XO,!9C.,!-,.=;6$X.(!.:!.8$+%(#(:!7#((+,!$%+=N!8+=!#(+77+6%#C!,+$$;,$;%(*%%+)$+!$.8!,+$;)%&%/!•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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!I!6.(6;,,&($+(N!.:!&%!=+!BM=+!9&,!8;)#:9+%+,!.:!#(_#%&8+(%+,!%#)!+(!$)#6!&%7+,=/!!<\,7.,=+)+,!Y!#!7.,8!&C!8.(.-.)#$%#$6!-,#$7&$%$+%%+)$+!#((+(7.,!6X+,(+C#,6$.89+%+(N!=#,+6%+!%#)$6;==!.:!)&C+N!,++))+!&C6&$%(#(:$6,&CN!+C+(%;+)%!#!6.8B#(&$X.(!8+=!&(=,+!6.(6;,,&($+7.,=+)+,!Y!:#,!7.,+%&6+(+!O6.(.8#$6!9&(=)#(:$,.8b!8M)$+%%#(:+,!.8!$%O,,+)$+!.:!C+6$%!7.,$%+,6+,!#(_#%&8+(%+(+!%#)!M!7.,=,#C+!6.(6;,,+(%+(+b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cd.C+($!7.,8M)!+,!M!7,+88+!6.(6;,,&($+!7.,!=+,#:X+((.8!M!B#=,&!%#)!+77+6%#C!B,;6!&C!$&87;((+%$!,+$$;,$+,/!"+=!&(C+(=+)$+!&C!=+((+!).C!$6&)!=+%!%&$!$\,)#:!9+($*(!%#)!7.,B,;6+,(+$!#(%+,+$$+,/c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e!2Z2!!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!a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fDa021J!!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!21!)$")*++,"-.'#((6XO-+(+!#!.77+(%)#:!$+6%.,!#!011IN!8+($!.77+(%)#:!7.,,+%(#(:$=,#7%!$%.!7.,!=+%!,+$%+,+(=+/!G77+(%)#:+!#((6XO-!;%:X.,=+!2?Na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e!Q!&!#!).C!.8!.77+(%)#:+!&($6&77+)$+,!&%!=+%!$6;))+!.--,+%%+$!+(!;&C9+(:#:!6)&:+(+8(=!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!&($6&77+)$+,/!F)&:+(+8(=&!VFG['W!%,M=%+!#!7;(6$X.(!2/!X&(;&,!011J/!>!011a!6.8!=+%!#((!0II!6)&:+$&6+,!%#)!FG['!9C.,&C!00I!+(=%+!8+=!+(!&C:XO,+)$+/![,&!2/X&(;&,!011Q!7#66!FG['!:+B*,8*(=#:9+%!.:!6&(!=+,8+=!;%$%+=+!:+B*,+,!%#)!&6%O,+,!$.8!.C+,%,+,!&($6&77+)$+$,+:)+8+(%+%/!!L+%!+6$#$%+,+,!-+,!#!=&:!#66+!+%!%#)$*($.,:&(!$.8!9&,!&($C&,!7.,!M!.C+,CM6+!8&,6+=+%!7.,!.77+(%)#:!#((6XO-/! <."-?".9'91%'.66.)912')$")*++,"-.'8,+.'&.%21-'12,+.9,99'g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gX+((.8!;%,+=(#(:$&,B+#=+%!9&,!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!#=+(%#7#$+,%!+(!,+66+!.8,M=+,!8+=!;7;))$%+(=#:!6.(6;,,&($+N!.:!;%&,B+#=+%!7.,$)&:!%#)!)O$(#(:+,/!!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!22!>!)#69+%!8+=!+,7&,#(:+,!.:!7;((!7,&!H.,:+!7#((+,!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!.8,M=+,!8+=!,+=;$+,%!8&,6+=$%#):&(:N!6.(6;,,&($+C,#=(#(:+,!.:!$C&69+%+,!C+=!+6$#$%+,+(=+!,+:+)C+,6!.:!%#)$*(/!3+*"&1:'*9+.&"1":'$:'6$+-%,:'91%'.66.)9121-.+1":''F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!V011a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a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• <#6,+!&%!6.88+,$#+))!C#,6$.89+%!$6#))+$!7,&!8*(=#:9+%$;%OC+)$+!• >((7O,+!+77+6%#C+!,+:)+,!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!$+6%.,$!$&):!&C!:,;((=&%&!+))+,!(O=C+(=#:!#(7.,8&$X.(!!• ]6+!8;)#:9+%+(+!7.,!M!+%%+,-,OC+!6.88;(&)+!B+$);%(#(:+,!!• ]6+!#(($*(+%!#!.77+(%)#:!C#,6$.89+%+,!• >((7O,+!+%!(&$X.(&)%!$%&%$%O%%+,+:)+8+(%!!• [.,B+=,+!%#)-&$(#(:+(!&C!$%&%$%O%%+,+:)+(+!!F.(6;,,&($+C+,6+%!7.,+$)M,!.:$M!M!7.,B*!$%&%)#:+!8*(=#:9+%+,!M!$+):+!C&,+,!.:!%X+(+$%+,!#!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!8&,6+=+,/!L+,$.8!=+%!+%&B)+,+$!6.(6;,,&($+!-M!)#6+!C#)6M,!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!%#)B*=+,+N!6&(!=+%!=#$6;%+,+$!.8!=+%!+,!

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• L+(!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!C#,6$.89+%+(!V#(($&8)#(:!.:!B+9&(=)#(:!&C!(\,#(:$&C7&))W!8.%%&,!C+,=#+,!#!7.,8!&C!%#):&(:!%#)!;(=+,-,#$+%!6&-#%&)!.:!;%$%*,!6(*%%+%!%#)!=,#7%!&C!=+%!).C-M)&:%+!&($C&,+%!V9;$9.)=(#(:$&C7&))W/!!!• L+%!.C+,#(C+$%+,+$!#!+6$+8-+)C#$!&C7&))$7.,B,+((#(:$&()+::/![.,!M!$#6,+!+(!B+$%!8;)#:!6&-&$#%+%$;%(*%%+)$+!=;8-+$!-,#$+(+!-M!(\,#(:$&C7&))!%#)!;(=+,!$+)C6.$%-,#$/!!• L+%!6,+C+$!)&C+,+!&C6&$%(#(:!-M!#(C+$%+,#(:+(!+((!c(.,8&)&C6&$%(#(:c/!!>!&))+!%#)7+))+(+!6&(!=+%!C\,+!B,;==!-M!,+:+)C+,6+%!7.,!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+N!.:3+))+,!6,*$$;B$#=#+,#(:!7,&!=+!).C-M)&:%+!%X+(+$%+(+!=+,!6.88;(+(!9&,!+(+,+%%!%#)!=+(!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(/!!<+)C6.$%-,#($#--+%!:XO,!=+%!#!-,#($#--+%!;).C)#:!M!6,+C+!#((!8+,!7.,!M!)+C+,+!).C-M)&:%+!%X+(+$%+,!+((!%X+(+$%+(!6.$%+,/!L+%!+,!=+,8+=!#66+!).C!M!$;B$#=#+,+!(\,#(:$&C7&))!8+=!#((%+6%+,!7,&!9;$9.)=(#(:$&C7&))/!L+%!6&(!#8#=)+,%#=!C\,+!C&($6+)#:!M!B+,+:(+!.:!7.,=+)+!6.$%(&=+(+/!!!L+,$.8!+(!6.88;(+!#(C+$%+,+,!#!+%!&C7&))$7.,B,+((#(:$&()+::!.:!6,+C+,!)&C+,+!&C6&$%(#(:!-M!#(C+$%+,#(:+(!+((!c(.,8&)&C6&$%(#(:cN!C#)!&()+::+%!6;((+!%#)B*!)&C+,+!-,#$+,!-M!(\,#(:$&C7&))!+((!+(!%#)$C&,+(=+!B+=,#7%!$.8!8M!)+C+,+!&C6&$%(#(:!-M!#(C+$%+,#(:+(+/!!E(=+,$O6+)$+,!:X+((.87O,%!&C!K_.(!V0114W!%*=+,!-M!&%!=+%!+,!%#)7+))+,!8+=!6.(6;,,&($+!-M!;)#6+!C#)6M,!#!&C7&))$B,&($X+(N!$+)C!.8!=+%!7#((+$!,+:+)Z!C+,6!$.8!$6&)!$#6,+!)#6+!,&88+B+%#(:+)$+,/!!!K(!,+C#$X.($,&--.,%!7,&!+(!$+)$6&-$6.(%,.))!#!

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iltak for mer likeverdig konkurranse MBA R96$+&+1":.+D'91%9,)'$:'21+).51&%.+''($")*++,"-.'/0'%1).'21%)0+'/0'%,":9'"S+'+.,%1-.+9'1',%%.'5,+).&.+'gX+((.8:&(:+(!#!7.,+:M+(=+!6&-#%%+)!C#$+,!&%!=+%!+,!C+)!=.6;8+(%+,%!&%!6.(6;,,&($+!-M!)#6+!C#)6M,!#!6.(6;,,&($+7)&%+(!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!C#,6$.89+%+,!-M!)&(:%!(\,!+,!,+&)#$+,%!#!&))+!8&,6+=+,/!gX+)=+(=+!6.(6;,,&($+).CN!7.,C&)%(#(:$).CN!).C!.8!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+!.:!).C!.8!.77+(%)#:!&($6&77+)$+,!#C&,+%&,!B&,+!=+)C#$!9+($*(+%!%#)!6.(6;,,&($+!-M!)#6+!C#)6M,!8+)).8!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!C#,6$.89+%+,/!!L+!(+C(%+!).C+(+$!7.,8M)!:,#-+,!#((!#!9C+,&(=,+!.:!BO,!C;,=+,+$!#!$&88+(9+(:/!d.C!.8!.77+(%)#:!&($6&77+)$+,!$6&)!B#=,&!%#)!C+)7;(:+,+(=+!8&,6+=+,!8+=!)#6!8&,6+=$&=:&(:!7.,!;)#6+!&6%O,+,!.:!,++))!6.(6;,,&($+!.8!)+C+,&($+,!&C!C&,+,!.:!%X+(+$%+,!%#)!$%&%!.:!6.88;(+/!F.(6;,,&($+).C+(!$6&)!7,+88+!6.(6;,,&($+!7.,!M!B#=,&!%#)!+77+6%#C!B,;6!&C!$&87;((+%$!,+$$;,$+,!.:!#((9.)=+,!7.,B;=!8.%!$&8&,B+#=!$.8!B+:,+($+,!6.(6;,,&($+!.:!8#$B,;6!&C!=.8#(+,+(=+!$%#))#(:/!d.C!.8!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+!$6&)!9#(=,+!6.(6;,,&($+C,#=(#(:!.:!$#6,+!7.,;%$#:B&,+!6.(6;,,&($+Z!.:!,&88+C#)6M,!#!9+)+!K]<Z.8,M=+%/!!=S+6$+&.%.+'$:'51-8+*)',2'&$51".+."&.'-91%%1":''E%7.,=,#(:+(+!#!6.(6;,,&($+7.,9.)=+%!8+)).8!-,#C&%!.:!.77+(%)#:!$+6%.,!9&,!.7%+!$#(!B&6:,;((!#!&%!.77+(%)#:+!&6%O,+,!-M!+(!+))+,!&((+(!8M%+!9&,!$\,7.,=+)+,!#!6,&7%!&C!$#(!-.$#$X.(!+))+,!8*(=#:9+%$-M)&:%+!.--:&C+,/!L+%%+!6&(!:#!$\,7.,=+)+,!$.8!6&(!;%(*%%+$!:X+((.8P!!• U&,6+=$8&6%!%#)!$6&=+!7.,!6.(6;,,+(%+(+!Y!+))+,!#!C+,$%+!7&))!;%+$%+(:+)$+!+))+,!B+:,+($+%!8&,6+=$&=:&(:!7.,!,++))+!6.(6;,,+(%+,3-,#C&%+!&6%O,+,/!!• F,*$$;B$#=#+,#(:!&C!=+(!7.,,+%(#(:$8+$$#:+!C#,6$.89+%+(!$.8!7O):+!&C!8.(.-.)#$%#$6!-,#$#(:!#!7.,C&)%(#(:$=+)+(N!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+N!)&C+!&C6&$%(#(:$6,&CN!+))+,!6.(6;,,&($+7.,=+)+,!$.8!7O):+!&C!$6&%%+,+:)+,N!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!2D!$;B$#=#+,!+%_!!•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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!24!'*6.1--':"0-06!'"$#..#"%!/!%#%N!.:!+,!=+,8+=!#66+!+%!8M)!#!$+:!$+)C/!U+=!$&87;(($O6.(.8#$6!+77+6%#C#%+%!8+(+$!=+%!&%!=+%!#66+!+,!8;)#:!M!.--(M!8+,!-M!+%%!.8,M=+!;%+(!M!$C+66+!+%!&((+%!.8,M=+!C+=!+(!&((+(!B,;6!&C!,+$$;,$+(+/!!L+((+!7.,$%M+)$+(!&C!+77+6%#C#%+%$B+:,+-+%!)+::+$!.:$M!%#)!:,;((!#!7.,&,B+#=+(+!%#)!6.(6;,,&($+).C+(/!L+%%+!7,+86.88+,!B)&(%!&((+%!#!HGE!2aa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aa2P!0Q!$#=+!I1P!hL+(!-,&6%#$6+N!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#$6+!%#)(\,8#(:$8M%+!8M!C\,+!M!B*::+!-M!+(!6.(6,+%!&(&)*$+!.:!C;,=+,#(:!&C!.8!&CC#6+%!7,&!7.,;%$+%(#(:+(+!i#!7,#6.(6;,,&($+8.=+))+(j!+,!$M!.87&%%+(=+!.:!&)C.,)#:+N!&%!=+%!#66+!6&(!7.,C+(%+$!&%!6.(6;,,&($+(!#!8&,6+=+,!7;(:+,+,!%#)$%,+66+)#:!+77+6%#C%!%#)!M!$#6,+!+77+6%#C!,+$$;,$B,;6/!SC#$!6.(6;,,&($+(!#!+%!:#%%!8&,6+=!;%!7,&!+(!$)#6!6.(6,+%!B+=O88#(:!&($+$!M!7;(:+,+!%#)$%,+66+)#:!+77+6%#C%N!C#)!;%C&):+%!B+%+:(+!=+%%+!$.8!C#,6$.8!6.(6;,,&($+/k!!F.(6;,,&($+(!+,!8+=!=+%%+!;%:&(:$-;(6%!C#,6$.8!(M,!=+(!B#=,&,!%#)!M!7,+88+!8M)+%!.8!+77+6%#C!B,;6!&C!$&87;((+%$!

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• G77+(%)#:!&($6&77+)$+,!• F.(6;,,&($+!8+)).8!.77+(%)#:+!.:!-,#C&%+!&6%O,+,!•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l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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!2a!-?".+:1.66.)9.+'2.&'.9'-,5%.9':+./',+:)+,!7.,!;)#6+!%*-+,!7.,!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+N!.:!,+:+)C+,6+%!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!&($6&77+)$+,!6&(!B+9&(=)+$!&C!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%/!!"M,!C;,=+,#(:!+,!&%!.--:&C+(+!6&(!)O$+$!C+=!+(!O6(#(:!-M!.8!)&:!21m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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!01!MBQ =?".+:1.+'6$+'5,+).&.9I'O,+).&-;8.:+."-"1":.+'$:')$")*++,"-.;2+1&"1":.+'K,7&,#(:+(+!7,&!=&:+($!8&,6+=!C#$+,!&%!.77+(%)#:!+(9+%+,3+%&%+,!#!8&(:+!%#)7+))+,!6&(!C\,+!%#)B*=+,!&C!C&,+,!.:!%X+(+$%+,!#!6.(6;,,&($+!8+=!-,#C&%+!%#)B*=+,+/!>!$)#6+!%#)7+))+,!6&(!6.88;(+,!.:!$%&%)#:+!+(9+%+,!.--%,+!BM=+!$.8!.--=,&:$:#C+,!.:!%#)B*=+,/!K(!6&(!=&!,#$#6+,+N!+(%+(!C+=!B+C#$$%+!9&(=)#(:+,!+))+,!8+,!;B+C#$$%N!&%!6.(6;,,&($+(!#(($6,+(6+$!.:!&%!C&,+(+!.:!%X+(+$%+(+!B)#,!=*,+,+!+))+,!&C!=M,)#:+,+!6C&)#%+%!+((!=+!+))+,$!6;((+!9&!B)#%%/!L+(!#(($6,+(6+%+!6.(6;,,&($+(!6&(!%&!7.,8!&C!&%!.77+(%)#:+!)+C+,&(=O,+,!6&(!9&!#(($#=+#(7.,8&$X.(!.:!6.(%&6%+,!$.8!:XO,!&%!=+!)+%%+,+!7M,!)+C+,+!C&,+,!.:!%X+(+$%+,N!&%!=+!6,*$$;B$#=#+,+$!C+=!&%!#(($&%$7&6%.,+,!B)#,!$%#)%!B#))#:+,+!%#)!=#$-.$#$X.(!7.,!=+8!+((!7.,!&(=,+!&6%O,+,N!.:!#!+6$%,+8+!%#)7+))+,!7M,!%#):&(:!-M!:,&%#$!#(($&%$7&6%.,+,/!!>(($6,+(6+%!6.(6;,,&($+!6&(!.:$M!6.88+!#!7.,8!&C!8&(:)+,!C+=!.77+(%)#:+!#((6XO-!C+=!&%!+(!6.88;(&)!#((6XO-+,!7.,+%,+66+,!B+$%+8%+!)+C+,&(=O,+,!V-,#C&%+!+))+,!.77+(%)#:+W!;%+(!&%!=+%%+!+,!6(*%%+%!%#)!6C&)#%+%!.:!-,#$!-M!=+!%X+(+$%+,!$.8!)+C+,+$/!U&(:+)7;))+!&(B;=$;%)*$(#(:+,!+))+,!&(=,+!7.,8+,!7.,!B+:,+($+=+!6.(6;,,&($+,!6&(!.:$M!:#!#(($6,+(6+%!6.(6;,,&($+/!!O,+).&--21)9'K6$+8-)+(+!.C+,!#));$%,+,+,!+6$#$%+($!&C!6.(6;,,&($+C,#=(#(:!.:!6.(6;,,&($+$6&=+)#:!&%7+,=!8+=!B+:,+($+%!8&,6+=$%#):&(:!+))+,!;%+$%+(:+)$+!&C!8&,6+=$&6%O,+,!$.8!8;)#:!;%7&))/!!G--$;88+,%!6&(!C#!$#!&%!6.(6;,,&($+7.,=+)+,!$.8!7O):+!&C!6,*$$;B$#=#+,#(:N!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+N!+(+,+%%!%#)!#(($&%$7&6%.,+,!+))+,!&(=,+!$\,C#)6M,!:#,!8;)#:9+%+,!7.,P!!• U&,6+=$-,#$+,!$.8!#66+!,+7)+6%+,+,!=+!,++))+!6.$%(&=+(+!Y!6&(!7.,%,+(:+!8+,!+77+6%#C+!6.(6;,,+(%+,!• E)#6!-,#$!-M!#(($&%$7&6%.,+,!$.8!7O):+!&C!+(+,+%%!+))+,!7.,=+)+,!6(*%%+%!%#)!7.,C&)%(#(:$.--:&C+,!Y!6&(!7.,%,+(:+!+))+,!;%+);66+!6.(6;,,+(%+,!• U&(:)+,!C+=!.77+(%)#:+!&(B;=!+))+,!8&(:)+(=+!;%)*$(#(:+,!Y!6&(!B+:,+($+!8&,6+=$%#):&(:+(!8+=!6.($+6C+($+,!7.,!&(%&))!.:!%*-+!8&,6+=$&6%O,+,!!• E%(*%%+)$+!&C!&$$*88+%,#$6!#(7.,8&$X.(!Y!6&(!:#!;)#6!8&,6+=$&=:&(:!.:!C+6%)+::#(:!&C!&(=,+!9+($*(!+((!+77+6%#C#%+%!.:!6C&)#%+%!!U&,6+=$6.($+6C+($+(+!7.,!7.,B,;6+,(+!6&(!C\,+!9O*+,+!-,#$+,N!8#(=,+!C&):7,#9+%N!.:3+))+,!)&C+,+!6C&)#%+%!-M!%#)B;=+%!#!+(6+)%+!$+6%.,+,/!!($++1:.+.+'5,+).&--21)9'[.,8M)+%!8+=!=+!7.,$)M%%+!%#)%&6+(+!+,!M!6.,,#:+,+!7.,!=+)+,!&C!=+(!.B$+,C+,%+!8&,6+=$$C#6%+(!:X+((.8!;%C#=+)$+!&C!6.(6;,,&($+).C+(!.:!+(!;%C#=+%!%#)$*($,.))+!#!

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d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• M!,+:($6&-$7O,+!7+))+$6.$%(&=+,!-M!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(/!!• .C+,#(C+$%+,+$!#!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!00!C#,6$.89+%+(!$)#6!&%!)+=#:!6&-&$#%+%!6&(!B,;6+$!%#)!M!-,.=;$+,+!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!%X+(+$%+,/!• #(C+$%+,+!#!-,.=;6$X.($%+6(.).:#!#!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(!$.8!:#,!)&C+!8&,:#(&)6.$%(&=+,!7.,!=+(!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(/!!F.$%(&=+(+!C+)%+$!=&!.C+,!-M!B,;6+,(+!&C!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!%X+(+$%+(!.:3+))+,!.77+(%)#:+!B;=$X+%%+,!=+,$.8!=+(!,+:;)+,%+!C#,6$.89+%+(!7#(&($#+,+$!9+)%!+))+,!=+)C#$!.C+,!.77+(%)#:+!B;=$X+%%+,/!L+(!6.(6;,,&($+;%$&%%+!=+)+(!&C!C#,6$.89+%+(!7M,!#!-,&6$#$!+(!=,#7%$$%O%%+!$.8!6&(!B,;6+$!%#)!M!9.)=+!-,#$+(+!(+=+N!.:!=+,8+=!7.,%,+(:+N!+))+,!B+:,+($+!8&,6+=$&=:&(:+(!%#)!&(=,+!)+C+,&(=O,+,!$.8!#!;%:&(:$-;(6%+%!6;((+!C\,%!6.(6;,,&($+=*6%#:+!=+,$.8!6.(6;,,&($+(!9&==+!7.,+:M%%!-M!)#6+!C#)6M,/!!cE(=+,-,#$#(:c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•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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!0J!$&87;(($8+$$#:+!O($6+)#:/!!>!C;,=+,#(:!&C!+77+6%#C#%+%$%&-!BO,!7.,8M)+%!+%!$;B$#=#;8!:#$!;(=+,N!$++$!#!$&88+(9+(:!8+=!6,&C+(+!%#)!+77+6%#C!,+$$;,$B,;6/![.,!OC,#:!.--$%M,!=+!$&88+!%*-+!%&-!$.8!#!%#)7+))+%!.C+,/!!L#$6,#8#(+,+(=+!-,#$#(:!&C!%#):&(:!%#)!#(7,&$%,;6%;,!+))+,!&(=,+!#(($&%$7&6%.,+,!$.8!6.(6;,,+(%+(+!+,!&C9+(:#:!&CN!6&(!.:$M!7.,+6.88+/!L+,$.8!+(!#(($&%$7&6%.,!6.(%,.))+,+$!&C!+(!.77+(%)#:+!&6%O,!:#,!=+%%+!8;)#:9+%+,!%#)!M!$+%%+!+(!9O*!-,#$!-M!#(($&%$7&6%.,+(!6.(6;,,+(%+(+!+,!&C9+(:#:!&C/!@+:,+($+%!8&,6+=$&=:&(:!.:!;%+);66+)$+!&C!8+,!6.$%(&=$+77+6%#C+!6.(6;,,+(%+,!6&(!C\,+!,+$;)%&%+%!.:$M!9+,/!!J66."9%1:.'1"")47/'$:'+$%%.8%,"&1":'T.))+B)&(=#(:!#!7.,B#(=+)$+!8+=!,+:;)+,#(:!&C!8&,6+=$%#):&(:!:X+((.8!.77+(%)#:+!#((6XO-!.:!7&$%$+%%+)$+!&C!-,.=;6$X.(!#!.77+(%)#:!.:!-,#C&%!,+:#N!6&(!7O,+!%#)P!• U&(:)+(=+!;%)*$(#(:!.:!=#,+6%+6XO-!!• E)#6!%#):&(:!%#)!#(7.,8&$X.(!Y!7&C.,#$+,#(:!&C!c+:+(!C#,6$.89+%c!• L#$6,#8#(+,+(=+!#((6XO-!!T+$;)%&%+%!6&(!C\,+!C+)7+,=$%&-!$.8!7O):+!&C!&%!cB+$%+c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g,;((+(!+,!&%!#!=&:!+,!.77+(%)#:!7.,,+%(#(:$C#,6$.89+%!.7%+!$%+,6%!#(%+:,+,%!8+=!=+(!.77+(%)#:!7.,C&)%(#(:$+(9+%+(!.:!+(!-,#$#(:!&C!B,;6!&C!

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!0D!.66.)91219.9-:.21"-9.+',+&)6&-#%&)!.:!7+))+$!%X+(+$%+,!&CC#6+,!M-+(B&,%!$C\,%!.7%+!7,&!-,#($#--+%!.8!&)%+,(&%#C6.$%(&=$-,#$#(:/!L+%!+,!+(!;%7.,=,#(:!7.,!=+(!.77+(%)#:+!7.,C&)%(#(:+(!.:!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%!M!7M!-M!-)&$$!+(!$)#6!-,#$#(:!&C!B,;6!&C!,+$$;,$+,/!K(!$)#6!-,#$#(:!C#)!.:$M!6;((+!:#!+77+6%#C#%+%$:+C#($%+,!7.,!$&87;((+%!C+=!&%!B,;6+(!&C!,+&)6&-#%&)!.:!7+))+$%X+(+$%+,!$6X+,!$)#6!&%!$&87;((+%!#66+!6&(!.--(M!(.+(!:+C#($%+,!C+=!M!.87.,=+)+!=+((+!B,;6+(/!J//-*55.+1":'N'91%9,).9'21%':1':.21"-9.+'L+%!;%C#=+%+!8&(=&%+%!%#)!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%!:XO,!&%!=+!6&(!:,#-+!#((!$.8!7O):+!&C!%#-$!+))+,!6)&:+,!+(%+(!-M!6XO-+,$#=+(!V6.88;(+!.:!$%&%W!C+=!.77+(%)#:!&($6&77+)$+,!+))+,!-M!)+C+,&(=O,$#=+(!C+=!)+C+,&($+,!%#)!.77+(%)#:+!+(9+%+,/!!T+:+)C+,6$+(=,#(:+(!8+=!%#)-&$$+=+!(&$X.(&)+!).C+,!7.,!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+N!#(6);=+,%!,+:)+,!8.%!6,*$$;B$#=#+,#(:!#!.77+(%)#:!$+6%.,N!6.,,#:+,+,!7.,!-MC#$%+!$C&69+%+,/!F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%!:#$!+%!C+,6%O*!8.%!.77+(%)#:+!8&,6+=$;%OC+,+!8+=!;%#)BO,)#:!;%(*%%+)$+!&C!=.8#(+,+(=+!$%#))#(:!-M!)#(X+!8+=!=+%!$.8!:X+)=+,!7.,!-,#C&%+!C#,6$.89+%+,/!!K%!7+))+$!).CC+,6!.:!%#)$*(!7.,!-,#C&%+!.:!.77+(%)#:+!7.,,+%(#(:$C#,6$.89+%+,!C#)!B#=,&!%#)!+(!$%O,,+!:,&=!&C!)#6+B+9&(=)#(:!.:!8+=!=+%%+!$%#8;)+,+!%#)!)#6+C+,=#:!6.(6;,,&($+!+%%+,!$&88+!$-#))+,+:)+,/!L+%%+!C#)!$%#8;)+,+!%#)!+(!8+,!+77+6%#C!;%(*%%+)$+!&C!$&87;((+%$!,+$$;,$+,/!!!!!!"#": ;.+4*&605<1(.5608/*21.21&*650170*+=*11L1+.)9.'91%9,)-)$-9",&.+'>!6&-#%%+)!J/J!6.(6);=+,+,!C#!8+=!&%!=+!7.,+$)M%%+!%#)%&6+(+!+,!:X+((.87O,B&,+!.:!&%!=+!&=8#(#$%,&%#C+!.:!O6.(.8#$6+!6.($+6C+($+(+!+,!B+:,+($+%/!K%!8+,!$&8)+%!:,+-!-M!F.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66+(!8+=!+(!$%O,,+!:,&=!&C!$&8.,=(#(:!&C!;)#6+!,+:+)C+,6!.:!6.8-+%&($+N!C#)!%,.)#:!C\,+!+77+6%#C#%+%$Z!.:!6C&)#%+%$7,+88+(=+!7.,!7.,C&)%(#(:+(/!!L+((+!%*-+!+77+6%+,!9&,!C#!#66+!C;,=+,%/!!(+,2'$5'$+:,"1-,9$+1-).'."&+1":.+'K%!8+,!6.(6;,,&($+-,+:+%!,+:#8+!#!7.,B#(=+)$+!8+=!.77+(%)#:+!&($6&77+)$+,!6&(!6,+C+!&%!7.,,+%(#(:$C#,6$.89+%N!=C$!)+C+,&(=O,+,N!#!.77+(%)#:!$+6%.,!.,:&(#$+,+$!#!+:(+!X;,#=#$6+!+(9+%+,!$.8!+,!&=$6#)%!7,&!6X+,(+C#,6$.89+%+(!%#)!=+(!.77+(%)#:!7.,C&)%(#(:$+(9+%+(!8+=!9+($*(!%#)!)+=+)$+!.:!&($&%%+/!L+%%+!C#)!6;((+!:#!(.+(!.8$%#))#(:$6.$%(&=+,!7.,!+(9+%+,!$.8!!6,+C+$!.8.,:&(#$+,%/!!>!%,M=!8+=!+6$#$%+,+(=+!,+:+)C+,6!7.,!$%&%$$%O%%+!+,!=+%!,#8+)#:!&%!=+(!(&$X.(&)+!%#)-&$(#(:!M-(+,!7.,!&%!).6&)+!8*(=#:9+%+,!V6.88;(+,W!:#$!9&(=)#(:$,.8!%#)!M!6.,,#:+,+!7.,!8&,6+=$$C#6%!9C#$!8&,6+=+%!#66+!7,&8B,#(:+,!$&87;(($:&:()#:+!)O$(#(:+,/!E((%&6!BO,!+6$+8-+)C#$!6;((+!:XO,+$!=+,$.8!=+%!7.,+)#::+,!$-+$#+))+!9+($*(!+))+,!=+%!6&(!:.=%:XO,+$!&%!=+%!7#((+$!

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• FG['!+,!6;(!+%!6)&:+.,:&(/!L+%%+!)+::+,!B+:,+($(#(:+,!-M!9C+8!$.8!9&,!6)&:+,+%%N!.:!6,+C+,!+(!&6%#C!9&(=)#(:!7,&!B+=,#7%+,!$.8!+,!;%$&%%!7.,!B,;==!-M!&($6&77+)$+$,+:)+8+(%+%/!!• [)+,+!B+=,#7%+,!9&,!:#%%!;%%,*66!7.,!&%!=+!C+:,+,!$+:!7.,!M!$+(=+!#((!+(!6)&:+$&6!#!,+=$+)!7.,!M!$%,&77+$!#!$+(+,+!&(B;=!• L+%!8&(:)+,!+(!%#-$%+)+7.(!.:!+(!8*(=#:9+%!$.8!6&(!:X+((.87O,+!%#)$*(!;%+(!&%!=+%!7.,+)#::+,!7.,8+))+!6)&:+,!• L+%!8&(:)+,!+(!7.,8+))!,M=:#C(#(:$%X+(+$%+,!7.,!.77+(%)#:+!#((6XO-$%X+(+$%+,/!@+=,#7%+(+!.--)+C+,!8&(:+!=M,)#:+!;%)*$(#(:+,!$.8!$6&-+,!8+,&,B+#=!BM=+!9.$!)+C+,&(=O,!.:!$+(+,+!6XO-+,!(M,!%#)B;=+(+!$6&)!B+9&(=)+$/!!• K(6+)%+!B+=,#7%+,!.--)+C+,!B+:,+($+%!8&,6+=$&=:&(:!$.8!7O):+!&C!+(!=.8#(+,+(=+!&6%O,!-M!#((6XO-$$#=+(!8+=!8&6%!%#)!M!B+:,+($+!6.(6;,,&($+(!• @+=,#7%+(+!.--)+C+,!%#)!=+)$!;6)&,+!,+:)+,!.:!-,&6$#$!7.,!B,;6!&C!.77+(%)#:!$%O%%+!.:!8&(:+)7;))!.C+,CM6#(:!&C!

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

5#)%&6!7.,!+(!8+,!9+)9+%)#:!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66!"#$%&!'(&)*$+!'<!!0I!Referanser @XO,(+(&6N!5,.(=b!L&:!U.,%+(!L&)+(N!H#)$ZS+(,#6!UO,_9!C.(!=+,![+9,!N!5,.(=!K/!G)$+(!.:!g&;%+!5.,$C#6!V011DWP!=5$&!"#$/!&"5(>$?-$*-*&8'#$*/$"0-"1((*-'#$6#&&06$0..#-%&!)#$0)$,(!/*%#$.0(#%*"@$F.(6;,,&($+%#)$*(+%!23011D/!G$).3@+,:+(!Y!7+B,;&,!011D!K_.(!V0114W!40-"1((*-'#.&*%#-$6#&&06$0..#-%&!)$0)$,(!/*%$(#-0/*'20-/!T&--.,%!0114Z1J2!F.(6;,,+(_+$%*,+)$+(!V011?WN!TM=$8O%+!0?/!(.C+8B+,!011?N!FOB+(9&C(P!F.(6;,,+(_+$%*,+)$+(/!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!V011?WN!A8-+!)7#%$0)$6*("-*+$B$%8+&!)*(#$)(C-'$6#&&*-$0..#-%&!)$0D7$,(!/*%@!T&--.,%!011?P?N!<%._69.)8P!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%/!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!V011aW!E%)C(+#($.F($;C%%(#$"0-"1((#-'$B$.F('&*)P!F.(6;,,+($C+,6+%!,&--.,%$+,#+!011aP?P!Kristiansand kommune (2009): Kontrollutvalget sak 29/09!HSG!V0121W!40-"1((*-'#$,5$&!"#$/!&"5(@$G3H'$7*-+&!-)',&*-$.0($"0-"1((*-'#$,5$&!"#$/!&"5(@!9%%-P33^^^/(9./(.3:+%7#)+/-9-3B#)=+,3T..%Hn37#)+,o.:oC+=)+::23S&(=)#(:$-)&(m016.(6;,,&($+m01-mKDm01)#6+m01C#)6mKD,/-=7!HGE!0112P!0I!L+)#(($%#))#(:!.8!+(=,#(:+,!#!6.(6;,,&($+).C:#C(#(:+(!!HGE!011JP!20!H*!6.(6;,,&($+).CN!!GK`L!V011?WN!901-+%*;&#$0-$(#)1&*%!-)$6*("#%$*D%!/!%!#'$;8$%7#$,1;&!D$'#D%0(/!A&,#$P!GK`L/!!<%/8+)=/!(,/!2D!V011?Z011DWP!G8!6.(6;,,&($+-.)#%#66+(!C.(!=+,![+9,N!H#)$ZS+(,#6!U/N!"#_%.,!L/!H.,8&(N!5.,:+,!T+C+!.:!'(=+,$!`9,/!</!T*$$=&)!V2aaIWN!I""#$.0($5$/!--#>J!<H[Z,&--.,%N!I3aI/!@+,:+(P!<&87;(($Z!.:!(\,#(:$)#C$7.,$6(#(:!'</!

Parse pdf-doc by clicking the button below. Parsed pdf-documents will be searchable.

Metadata Found
Author
Ingeborg Rasmussen
Producer
Mac OS X 10.6.5 Quartz PDFContext
CreationDate
2011-01-11T10:19:48+00:00
ModDate
2011-01-11T10:19:48+00:00
Pages
29